MORE FROM REELTALK:
 
  PODCAST
subscribe now
 
  CONTESTS  
  CHAT  
  MAIL THE EDITORS
 


myspace logo.jpg  
 
10top10_logo.gif
Posted by Jeffrey Lyons on 06/27/08 at 10:38 AM

raging bull.jpgOn this weekend's show, I took issue with some of the AFI’s choices for best films in ten genres. Here are some which time didn't permit us to include on air: Later, I’ve added some categories of my own, and since they're my categories, I get to put as many movies in them as I wish. Enjoy!

For sports movie’s, "Raging Bull" was a fine choice, but mine is "Field of Dreams" or maybe "Jim Thorpe, All-American"..."To Kill a Mockingbird" is another great choice, though I'd pick "12 Angry Men" for drama, if a jury room drama fits that category.

bridge on the river kwai.jpgFor epic, I can't quarrel with "Lawrence of Arabia," though I'd have picked "Bridge on The River Kwai"...same director, just as good. "2001, a Space Odyssey" is a great choice for science fiction, but I enjoyed "Star Wars" even more...finally "Vertigo" as best mystery? I'd pick "Rear Window" or maybe "North by Northwest," all three Hitchcock classics.

Other Western Classics: "3:10 to Yuma," (both versions), "The Gunfighter", "How the West Was Won" (Eli Wallach stole that one), and "Hondo." Also "Nevada Smith.”

Best Revolutionary war movies: "Drums Along the Mohawk", "The Devil's Disciple"...

blazing saddles.jpgFunniest films: "A Night at the Opera," "Blazing Saddles."

Best WWII movies; "The Counterfeit Traitor, " "The Man Who Never Was," "The Longest Day," "Saving Private Ryan," "30 Seconds Over Tokyo," "Tora,Tora,Tora," "From Here to Eternity", "Five Fingers" " Night of the Generals", "Judgement at Nuhremberg", "The Desert Fox" and of course "Patton.” "The Gallant Hours," "Bridge on the River Kwai" (my favorite, also in another category: epics,)"Back to Bataan" and "The Sands of Iwo Jima."

Scariest films: "Jaws", "The Exorcist" ...and anything with the Olsen twins.


Comments

SNOW WHITE!? OMG! ANYTHING by Disney/Pixar is better than that. It's a very old film that was a mediocre story in its time. TV really made it the "instiution" that people seem to think it is. True that Disney set a high animation standard, but not high enough to make this a top 10 all time choice. AFI needs to get some new blood in there.

Posted by: Michael Shaver | June 28, 2008 09:14 AM

My biggest problem with AFI's 10 top 10 lists was the implication that old movies = better movies. I respect and appreciate classic films, but it's awfully presumptious to say that only the movies made in what seems like ancient times to me, are the best of the best, and nothing signifigant has been done in the past 20 years. The most recent film to gain a number one spot was 1980's Raging Bull (sports). And even that should have gone to Rocky.

Romantic Comedies did well with both Sleepless in Seattle and When Harry Met Sally, but then they put a silent film as number 1. I love and own City Lights, but isn't one of the strengths of the RomCom supposed to be witty dialogue and the overall BANTER between the two leads?

Only 1 modern movie in the Courtroom Drama category (A Few Good Men), only 1 in mystery (Usual Suspects- really?), and only 1 in Westerns (Unforgiven). I would have liked to have seen Tombstone.

Even categories I was sure would see respect to the advances of modern movie making (Animation and Sci-Fi) still insisted on hitting us with oldies; Snow White for the win (?) 2001 over Star Wars? I missed The Incredibles, The Little Mermaid (which saved animation in the 80s), Close Encounters, and The Matrix (has changed the way FX are used in movies forever).

I would have liked to see Braveheart or Gladiator or Dances With Wolves in the epic category. All are modern classics that fit right in with Ben Hur and Lawrence of Arabia. War movies belong somewhere else.

I just don't get it. We can always argue about the placement of a certain film, but to see films I've never even heard of (Adam's Rib? Laura? Cat Ballou?), mis-labeling (King Kong, fantasy? Clockwork Orange, Sci-fi?), and unecessary pandering (The Godfather as #1 gangster is so obvious that creating a an entire list was just a waste of time) is annoying. I watch AFI's countdowns every year, and this time, they really let me down.

Posted by: Rob Grizzly | June 29, 2008 11:13 AM

  
Post a comment
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
  
  
  

Remember personal info?
Comments: (you may use HTML tags for style)
 
Web Producer: Jessica Bianculli