MORE FROM REELTALK:
 
  PODCAST
subscribe now
 
  CONTESTS  
  CHAT  
  MAIL THE EDITORS
 


myspace logo.jpg  
 
10top10_logo.gif
Posted by Alison Bailes on 06/27/08 at 10:59 AM

toy_story_ver1.jpgOn the show this week Jeffrey aired his beef with the AFI top ten lists.

Although I think it is almost impossible to pick “best ever” films…it’s also subjective…here are my choices, which do of course differ from Jeffrey’s.

1. Animation: I would have to go with “Toy Story”. I believe that each list has to change with the times…. “Snow White” is a beautiful film, but I’m not so sure kids would sit still through it these days. “Toy Story” combines the innocence of childhood, with the hipness of the nineties and the excitement of a modern action adventure.
2. Romantic comedy: here I agree with Jeffrey. “Annie Hall” is possibly my favorite film ever.high noon.jpg
3. Western: not my Favorite genre. My pick is “High Noon” for its tight running time and insane amount of tension packed in.
4. Sports movie: I can’t believe “Breaking Away” made this list…and I’m a cycling fan!!! I would pick “Rocky” as it’s the template for every underdog sports movie to follow. And a labor of love for Stallone.
5. Mystery: I never understood the appeal of “Vertigo”. And “the Maltese Falcon” just seems needlessly complicated. I pick “North by Northwest” because Cary Grant was ever the innocent everyman caught up in circumstances out of his control.
6. Fantasy: who can argue with “The Wizard of Oz”? god-father-07-py-01.jpg
7. Sci fi: I also have to agree with “2001: a Space Odyssey”. A masterpiece of foresight, mood and mystery.
8. Gangster: you can’t even discuss gangster films without reference to “The Godfather.” It is the paragon that all others are compared to.
9. Courtroom Drama: I’d have to go with “a Few Good Men.” The scenes with Jack Nicholson on the stand still give me chills.
10. Epic: although I love “Spartacus”…“Lawrence of Arabia” by David Lean defines epic. Sweeping, intimate, adventurous and tragic.


Comments

1. My Neighbor Totoro
2. His Girl Friday
3. Once Upon a Time in the West
4. Bull Durham
5. The Third Man
6. Wizard of Oz; (also Babe 1 & 2)
7. 2001; (also Close Encounters)
8. The Godfather 1 & 2
9. The Caine Mutiny
10. Lawrence of Arabia

Posted by: Leonard Dixon | June 28, 2008 06:48 PM

AFI's 10 top 10 confused me in some ways. They examined the best films in "10 classic genres," but there was no list for Action/Adventure (Raiders of the Lost Arc), Musical (Singin' in the Rain), or Thriller (Psycho, Silence of the Lambs).
Yet they had Gangster and Courtroom drama (?), which are obviously sub genres.
I don't understand their definition of Fantasy (Field of dreams? Groundhog day?) and they seemed to sweep War movies, a genre all it's own, into the epic category with things like Titanic and Schindler's List (?) which is a docu-drama.
Failing to put Rudy in the sports category for Jerry Maguire, a romance with some football in it, is a crime.

Posted by: Rob Grizzly | June 29, 2008 10:25 AM

  
Post a comment
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
  
  
  

Remember personal info?
Comments: (you may use HTML tags for style)
 
Web Producer: Jessica Bianculli