MORE FROM REELTALK:
 
  PODCASTS  
  CONTESTS  
  CHAT  
  TIP THE EDITORS


myspace logo.jpg  
 
Documentary Fatigue
Posted by Alison Bailes on 03/31/08 at 02:23 PM

I love a good documentary, but right now it seems that the market is flooded. I think it’s because many filmmakers are shooting on video and it has become relatively cheap to put something out there.

But what this results in is a diluted product pool. Any one can find an interesting subject and turn the camera on. But does that mean the subject merits 90 minutes of our time?
Recently I’ve seen two documentaries that have seemed to be a better fit for a television program such as “20/20” or “Dateline”.

“Fighting for Life” is about doctors in the army who are trained in battle surgery. Interesting, sure. But after about an hour the film had made its point and then watching soldiers being rehabilitated turned into a promotional video for the rehab facility.

“Hats Off” is about an eccentric, vivacious 93 year old actress who lives in NY and still goes on auditions. You might recognize her from “Sex and the City” (Stanford’s grandmother) or “Hitch” (old lady at wedding). She has a Katherine Hepburn look about her and an indefatigable attitude. But after about 40 minutes of her life story, I started to feel that I was flipping through someone else’s family album.

Some subjects just shouldn’t be stretched to fit the 90 minute formula, or we should get used to seeing ‘shorts’ and not feel like we’re being short-changed.


Comments

Hmm.
I'm acutally not the biggest fan of documentaries. Given the choice, I'd go with the mindless popcorn flick 9 outta 10 times.
But there have been some good ones that have grabbed me, and I appreciate any filmmaker who is willing to give up control over what they shoot (which is essentially what a documentary is).
I think it comes down to what you said- Have they found a story? Sure everyone has a tale to tell, but like any good movie (doc or not) audience interest has to be kept. Structure, characterization, and conflict are the key elements to telling said story, in any medium. I guess with festival season well underway, an onslaught of docs is something critics just have to endure- :)

Posted by: Rob Grizzly | April 1, 2008 03:06 PM

  
Post a comment
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
  
  
  

Remember personal info?
Comments: (you may use HTML tags for style)
 
Web Producer: Jessica Bianculli